Wastewater Treatment Plant Project: Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy Generation
A Minnesota Department of Commerce, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency and MnTAP project, funded through a grant from the U.S. Department of Energy, aimed to increase energy efficiency (E2) in Minnesota municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) and scope opportunities for onsite power generation. The project was completed in 2017.
The primary goals of the project were to:
- help wastewater facilities lower operating costs through improved energy efficiency, and
- provide up-to-date information to help facilities and city staff make informed decisions.
Wastewater treatment is a highly varied industry in Minnesota, both in the amount of energy consumed and the selection of treatment operations and equipment. Across the U.S., WWTPs are responsible for 1.5% of U.S. electrical consumption. Energy is one of the largest contributors to plant operational costs, and has the greatest potential for cost reduction. MnTAP engaged treatment plants to participate in a range of efforts to improve plant energy performance to reduce costs.
During the project, MnTAP sought to engage WWTPs that were:
- Making capital improvements – either expanding or redesigning portions of their plants.
- Willing to consider cost-effective changes to reduce total cost of plant operation.
- Using anaerobic digestion or considering changing to anaerobic digestion.
- Exploring the potential of utilizing biogas via combined heat and power (CHP) to generate electricity and offset natural gas purchases.
- Willing to host a MnTAP site assessment or a summer intern to evaluate efficiency opportunities on energy-intensive processing equipment, procedures and operating schedules.
- ENERGY STAR® Portfolio Manager® score
This is an energy benchmark for mechanical wastewater plants that compares your energy performance to plants nationally to identify operating cost reduction potential. This score accounts for differences in hydraulic and organic loads, climate and other factors and has been validated for plants larger than 0.6MGD (although we believe the model is likely to be useful for smaller plants also).
- Energy Assessments
MnTAP conducted assessments at eleven mechanical wastewater plants and one aerated pond system. These assessments:
- Evaluated current operations to identify energy efficiency and cost saving opportunities as well as possible ways to streamline operations and address maintenance issues
- Evaluated portions of planned expansions and plant modifications by working with your design engineers to look at capital investment vs. energy cost over the life of the plant to identify the most cost effective options.
- Delivered energy reduction solutions for voluntary implementation.
- Had no assessment fees and no regulatory burdens.
- Biogas Utilization Evaluations
For plants that produced biogas through anaerobic digestion, or were interested in evaluating biogas energy generation opportunities, MnTAP facilitated:
- A no-cost screening evaluation with the US DOE Midwest CHP Technical Assistance Partnership (CHP TAP)*. The screenings indicated if electrical power generation and thermal recovery (i.e. combined heat and power) from biogas appeared promising, or under what future conditions it might become promising.
- Follow on technical assistance, including engineering evaluation and/or feasibility study, through the US DOE Midwest CHP TAP to confirm cost effectiveness for promising CHP situations, and to characterize an appropriate biogas and CHP configuration.*The Midwest CHP Technical Assistance Partnership is a DOE supported regional center promoting and assisting in developing the market for Combined Heat and Power (CHP) technologies.
- Information on State and Federal Financial Assistance
As appropriate to needs, MnTAP facilitated connections to additional providers of financial assistance ranging from utility incentives to low-interest loans, to state vetted, energy performance contracts.
- MnTAP intern
MnTAP provided interns to work on an energy conservation projects of importance to 3 plants. Upper class, undergraduate students performed feasibility analyses to help plants select and justify the best options for process improvement, and begin the process of implementing change.
Project outcomes for the three-year project include:
- Trained 108 operators on Energy Efficiency (E2) and onsite power generation
- Conducted 12 E2 assessments at sites that are more complex than simple lagoon systems
- Identified a conservation opportunity of 5.5 million kWh per year
- Held 11 regional discussions on WWTP E2 implementation planning
- Evaluated 4 combined heat and power (CHP) screenings
Read the Final Project Report to get a comprehensive review of the project work and outcomes.
Read the Action Plan to review guidance provided to USDOE that aims to help other states emulate our project.
To learn more about this project, contact Karl DeWahl, MnTAP Team Leader and Senior Engineer, at 612-624-4645.
- WWTP GreenStep Cities Benchmarking Wastewater Treatment Plants 2017 – Jon Vanyo
- WWTP GreenStep Cities Benchmarking Wastewater Treatment Plants 2017 – Cheri Schneider
- WWTP GreenStep Cities Benchmarking Wastewater Treatment Plants 2017 – Scott Warner
- WWTP GreenStep Cities Benchmarking Wastewater Treatment Plants 2017 – Tracy Hodel
MnTAP Handout | B3 Benchmarking Capabilities
- Registration & Networking
- Welcome, GSC Background & Related Best Practices: Abby Finis, Great Plains Institute
- The Value of Benchmarking Wastewater Treatment: Jon Vanyo, Minnesota Technical Assistance Program
- B3 Benchmarking & Wastewater Treament Plants: Cheri Schneider, The Weidt Group Inc
- Case Studies: Scott Warner, City of New Prague
- Case Studies: Tracy Hodel, City of St Cloud
February 9, 2017 – MN B3 Benchmarking WWTP Overview Demonstration
Recording of webinar presented by Cheri Schneider of The Weidt Group on February 9, 2017 to introduce new functionality for Minnesota’s B3 Benchmarking platform – the ability to compute metrics specific to wastewater treatment plants.
March 24th, 2016 – Wastewater Treatment Energy Efficiency Training
Operating efficiently–energy conservation for small to medium wastewater treatment facilities
Course Instructor: Tom Jenkins, PE – JenTech Inc.
Training Slides [PDF]
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – Financing Handout
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – Agenda Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – M.Bohren Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – S.Smith Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – B.Sabie B.Dunn Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – P.Berger Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – A.Cecchini Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – P.Klein Slides
- Green Steps WWTP 2016 – E.Rehm Slides
January 13, 2016 – GreenStep Cities Workshop Follow-Up Session
Financing Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy at Wastewater Treatment Plants
- Agenda and Presenter Bios
- Case Study #1: Western Lake Superior Sanitary District (WLSSD)
- Case Study #2: Metropolitan Council
- Financing Mechanisms:
MnTAP assessed 10 sites in a previous project and has had a number of intern projects related to wastewater plant energy conservation. We found opportunities to reduce energy use by 5–30%.
- Wastewater Pond Efficiency Altura, MN Case Study – Saves $14,000 per year
- Pelican Rapids Wastewater Plant Case Study – Energy Efficiency saved $11,600 per year
- Pine River Area Sanitary District Case Study – Wastewaster Efficiency saved $4,100 per year
- Northfield Wastewater Treatment Plant Case Study – Wastewater Efficiency with potential savings of $93,300 per year
- Kasson Wastewater Treatment Plant Case Study – Assessment recommendations to save $18,000
- 2015 MnTAP Source Newsletter (pages 4-5) – Why Benchmark energy use
- 2013 City of Hutchinson intern project – intern project that saved $45,000
- 2014 City of St. Cloud intern project – intern project that saved $27,000 and recommends changes to save $54,000 more
- NorthBranch-Best Practices – what this small plant did to be in the top 6% nationally in energy efficiency
- 2011 Intern Project at the City of Rogers (2011 EBR page 15) – Intern project that saves $15,000
- 2011-12 WWTP Project Summary (2012 EBR page 16)
- Energy Benchmarking Handout
The Minnesota Department of Commerce is a Partner in the U.S. Department of Energy’s (U.S. DOE) Wastewater Infrastructure Accelerator. The U.S. DOE Wastewater Infrastructure Accelerator is a separate initiative than Wastewater Treatment Plant Project: Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Generation outlined above. Do not contact MnTAP for more information, contact Lindsay Anderson with the Minnesota Department of Commerce at email@example.com or 651-539- 1771.
According to the U.S. DOE, “The Wastewater Infrastructure Accelerator will work over three years with state, regional, and local agencies that are engaging with water resource recovery facilities in their jurisdiction to accelerate a pathway toward a sustainable infrastructure of the future. The Accelerator aims to catalyze the adoption of innovative and best-practice approaches in data management, technologies, and financing for infrastructure improvement. Partners will seek to improve the energy efficiency of their participating water resource recovery facilities by at least 30 percent and integrate at least one resource recovery measure.”
Learn more about the benefits from the Wastewater Infrastructure Accelerator Factsheet.
Contact: Lindsay Anderson with the Minnesota Department of Commerce at firstname.lastname@example.org or 651-539- 1771 to learn more or to sign-up.